Is my Christmas wish list outrageous?

I enjoy exploring ideas that challenge long-held beliefs and upend my thinking. That’s why I like listening to Ted Talks. And it’s why I love the teachings of Jesus.

Jesus’ parable about the bags of gold reminded me of a Ted Talk by Dan Pallotta entitled, “How we think about charity is dead wrong.” And it prompted me to write my Christmas wish list.

Here are a few things I want for Christmas: elimination of hunger and homelessness, quality health and dental care for everyone, treatment for the addicted, services for the elderly, a cure for cancer and AIDS.

Is my wish list outrageous? I used to think so, but now I know better.

Photo by pixabay, edits by author

Jesus said a man went on a trip and entrusted his wealth to three servants. To one he gave five bags of gold, to another two bags, and another one bag – according to their abilities.

When the master returned the first two servants multiplied his wealth, and he rewarded them, giving them more to manage. But the third servant buried his treasure. His excuse for hoarding the gold? Fear.

The master was harsh with the nonproductive servant, calling him lazy and wicked. He gave the slacker’s bag of gold to the successful investors and evicted him.

But what if the outcast who buried his gold was operating under a different set of rules than the favored servants? Using what I learned from Dan’s talk I present an alternative story.

The first two servants used their bags of gold to start a company called Amazon. They obtained investors who supported their innovative business model. There were failures along the way, but after six years the business turned a profit, multiplying the bags of gold many times.

The third servant – let’s call him Clark Griswold – worked for a non-profit organization committed to feeding the hungry. He wanted to hire the brightest MBAs from top schools, and they wanted to work for his cause. But they had student loans and couldn’t afford to live on the salary Clark offered them from his single bag of gold.

Clark wasn’t allowed to make investments and he kept expenses to a minimum. He feared losing everything if he used his masters’ gold to turn a profit, even for a noble cause. He fed a few people and tried to ignore the cries of the multitudes he turned away.

Dan Pallatto knows first hand that Clark’s fears were well-founded. He says the outdated rulebook for nonprofits forces people like Clark to bury their treasures.

Could this be why the poverty level In the United States has been 12% for the past forty years, and only 2% of the GDP goes to the nonprofit segment?

In 1994 Dan Pallatto built a for-profit charity company called Pallatto TeamWorks. And he refused to bury his treasure.

He adopted the same techniques that Amazon used to succeed. He paid decent salaries, spent money on advertising and marketing, took risks, and over time he multiplied his gold.

In nine years, Dan’s team raised $582 million dollars for AIDs services, breast cancer research, and suicide prevention. But the media crucified him. He lost his sponsors, and the company closed.

As Dan Pallatto said, “You want to make fifty million dollars selling violent video games to kids, go for it. We’ll put you on the cover of Wired magazine. But you want to make half a million dollars trying to cure kids of malaria, and you’re considered a parasite yourself.”

I envision Jesus saying to Dan, “Well done, good and faithful servant. Now let’s help the Clarks of the world dig up their treasures and multiply them, bringing my kingdom to earth as it is in heaven.”

Do you think my wish list could come true if we changed the rules for nonprofit organizations? I hope you’ll listen to Dan’s talk. He’s written several books, too. I don’t get any compensation if you buy one but I’d be thrilled if it changed your thinking. Please share this to spread the idea that the rules need to change so we can change the world. 

Boomer on the Ledge doll available with book in my online store.


©2017, Stevens. All rights reserved.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

32 thoughts on “Is my Christmas wish list outrageous?

  1. Thank you for sharing this thought-provoking post on #BloggingGrandmothersLinkParty. I’ve always thought if people can earn money doing good for others, that’s a win-win situation.

  2. My sis works for a non profit so I understand your wishes and in a perfect world there would be equal balance as too much of a good thing often hides disparity and corruption. So more is the way to go strike a balance at least. Your video is superb. thank you.

  3. Molly – thank you for posting this. It really did open my eyes to the issues that non-profits face and how many have been demonized over the years. Great food for thought! As always…you either get me laughing or get me thinking!

    • What a gift to know that this post has helped people see things with a new viewpoint. I have been passionate about this for a while and it seemed appropriate to post before Christmas, bringing in one of Jesus’ parables. Thank you so much for the comment! You made my day, Sheri.

    • The group that put a stop to Dan Pallotta’s efforts was the media. They wouldn’t tolerate a person running a charitable organization making a decent salary. he wasn’t even making the millions that so many CEOs make who work for companies that are not working for the good of humans. And they trashed him. If you listen to his talk you’ll hear the emotion he felt the day he had to lay off everyone in his company. Thanks for commenting.

  4. This is exactly what my son has been studying at college, Molly. Our 50 minute conversation last week was about this. I’m delighted that it’s spreading like wildfire amongst the youth, at least in his world.

    • That is terrific, Kelly. What is his major and where is he studying? I hope the rules for charity organizations changes so they can raise money with the same freedom that other companies do to make profits. There is plenty to go around if we could tap into the resources we have in more than a perfunctory way.

  5. Great post, Molly. My thoughts about this align with yours. I think it comes down to intent and unfortunately intent can’t be legislated. There are companies and individuals who are all about profits and wealth for themselves, and then there are almost identical companies and individuals who are devoted to creating healthy communities and raising everyone up with them. The difference seems to come down to values, which at this time in our nation seems to be hoarding money. I hope that someday soon we will, as a people, experience a realignment of values and that someone’s “worth” will be measured by their kindness and generosity, not their bank account. 😀 <3

    • I agree, Diana. I don’t have a problem with someone having a decent bank account. I just want companies that raise money for charities to not be crucified for having overhead costs to get the job done. We invest in stocks and don’t worry about the obscene salary of the CEO as long as the stock pays dividends or grows, but if the CEO of a company that raises money for charity makes more than minimum wage we judge him or her as a demon. It’s time to give everyone a level playing field. If we allowed the same innovations and investments in companies that work for the good, we could solve homelessness and so many more problems that plague us.

  6. Your list is far from outrageous. It’s spot on. So many things in our world aren’t working – it’s high time we changed our long held assumptions and ways of doing things.

  7. Very interesting approach by Dan P. I suppose some entrepreneurs could do what he did only for selfish profit reasons, but it sounds like he had the best of motives.

I love comments. Just type in the box below to make me happy, okay?